Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Reason #1: I Am an Individual, Not a Gender Identity
3. Reason #2: I Don't Care What People Call Me
4. Reason #3: Focusing on Gender Pronouns Sexualizes People and Triggers Me
5. Reason #4: I Do Not Care About Being Misgendered
6. Reason #5: I Do Not Want to Be Referred To
7. Conclusion
Content
1. Introduction
A pronoun is a
word or phrase used to refer to someone or something. Gender pronouns (or
gender-based pronouns) are used to refer to a person by their gender, as
shorthand, in place of their name.
Over the last
several years, it has become more and more common - especially in socially
liberal or left-leaning circles - to provide one's gender-based pronouns, while
introducing oneself to a new group of people.
I have
encountered this phenomenon twice so far in my life; once in a union meeting,
and again for a meeting of environmentalists.
I have written
this article in order to explain why I do not feel comfortable introducing
myself using gender pronouns.
2. Reason #1: I Am an Individual, Not a Gender Identity
For one, my
gender identity is not an integral part of my identity. I do not primarily
identify as a man, a woman, male, nor female, nor anything else "in
between" nor "other". What I primarily identify
as, is an individual.
If someone
wishes to refer to me, then I would hope that they would refer to me as
"Joe" (my first name), or as "Joseph", "Joey", or
"Joe Kopsick" (or my full name "Joseph William Kopsick").
Notice that I
said "hope". I hope that people refer to me by my
chosen name. If someone wants to call me "Steve", "Billy",
"Josephine", "Princess", or "X AE A-12", that is
their choice. Attempting to refer to me by that name would be completely
unproductive, and would only confuse people about to whom they're referring.
But it would not offend or insult me.
3. Reason #2: I Don't Care What People Call Me
There is no
point in getting "offended" or "insulted" when someone
refers to you by the wrong name. If they're doing it on purpose, then I would
understand feeling offended. But even if a person is trying to
offend or insult you, nobody can actually make you feel one
way or another. Your feelings are under your control.
If you suspect
that someone is trying to hurt your feelings by calling you by
the incorrect name, then you have every right to confront the person about
that. As long as you remember that feeling insulted, or saying "I'm
offended", doesn't give you any extra rights.
All you can do
is inform people of the name, or pronouns, with which you would like to
be referred, and hope that they respond in-kind. You cannot make someone
refer to you by any name, because they are in control of their mouths and voice
boxes; not you.
I have no
preferences regarding what I would like people to call me. As I explained, if
they don't call me "Joe", then I may suspect that they are talking
about somebody else. But I am not about to start ordering people to call me by
any particular name, nor by any particular set of pronouns.
That's because I
am not a grammar Nazi, nor a control freak. I do not care what people call me.
4. Reason #3: Focusing on Gender Pronouns Sexualizes People and Triggers Me
Another reason why I don't care whether people call me by
he/him pronouns, she/her pronouns, or anything else, is because I consider the
use of gender-based pronouns to be sexualizing.
If I were introducing myself with as much attention to
gender as the rest of the group would wish, then I would be allowing them to
refer to me with a reference to my sex or gender, instead of with a reference
to my individuality (the easiest way to do so being to use my first name).
As I explained, I primarily consider myself to be an individual human
being, rather than as a member of the male biological sex, or the masculine
gender, or the female biological sex, or the feminine gender, or anything else.
I am not primarily a member of any group; I
identify as myself.
Even though (as far as I know) I have XY sex chromosomes,
that fact does not dictate my identity as much as some people might assume it
does. If socially tolerant people are correct - and gender is fluid, and
biological sex does not dictate who you're attracted to, nor whom you love, nor
whether you are more masculine or feminine - then telling you that I
identify as male should not tell you jack shit about who I am as a person.
In my opinion, treating my sex or gender as an integral
part of who I am, is just submission to the false assumption (ironically shared
by socially "tolerant" people) that telling you my gender identity
will tell you everything (or anything) that you need to know about
me. It does not.
I could allow you to refer to me by "he/him"
pronouns, but that would be denying that I have a feminine side. I could allow
you to refer to me by "she/her" pronouns - as a way of recognizing my
feminine side - but that would only be a distraction from the fact that I have
XY sex chromosomes and the external genital appearances characteristic of a
biological male (i.e., a penis and testicles).
I was molested as a child.
When I tried to grow my hair
long in high school, I was treated as if I were a girl; as if having long hair
alone, made me a girl or a woman. I knew then that that was not so, and I still
know it today.
When I introduce myself to a new group of people, I want them
to know what my first name is. That is the way that we all grew up introducing
ourselves, and there is no need for that to change. I do not say this out of
lack of tolerance for transgender individuals; I say it because there is no
need to overload people with information about me aside from my name.
Also, I do not want people to be thinking about my
dick and balls just because I am meeting them for the first time.
Parents in the Millennial generation (my generation) have
spoken up recently about the fact that babies are routinely dressed in
gender-specific ways; blue for boys, and pink for girls. It used to be the
other way around, actually; blood-red used to stand for males (many of whom
became soldiers) while sky-blue stood for the peaceful nurturing nature
associated with females.
Several years ago, a "gender-reveal party" caused
a wildfire that burned down twenty-two thousand acres of California wilderness. Millennial
parents were quick to point out that that wildfire was an indication that
people's obsession with their children's genders has gotten out of hand.
You can read about that fire at the following link:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Dorado_Fire
People do not need to be thinking about your child's
genitals when you inform them that you have given birth to a baby. Similarly,
people do not need to know that I have a penis and testicles in order to know
that I like to be called Joe.
Do you need to know that I have a dick, or XY sex
chromosomes - or know that I have no plans to take hormones or get surgery - in order to call me by my preferred name of Joe? No, you don't.
Groups that ask people to introduce themselves with their
name and gender pronouns, should think about the fact that many people have
sexual trauma in their past.
Having to decide whether I am more masculine or feminine, in front of a group of strangers, is triggering for me; it traumatizes me and causes me to think about the complicated past I have in terms of trying to figure out what my gender identity is or is not.
When I am told "Please introduce yourself and tell us
your pronouns", I am no longer looking forward to the meeting; now I am
anxiously worrying about how to deal with referencing my sexual or gender
identity. I am worrying about how to avoid being objectified sexually, or
sexualized, when all I should be doing is waiting to tell people what my name
is.
After I introduce myself, people should be thinking about
the fact that my name is Joe. They should not be thinking about whether I have
a penis, whether I am attracted to men, nor whether I am taking hormones or
seeking gender confirmation surgery.
The person who molested me as a child, was obsessed with my
appearance and sexuality and my sex. I grew up fixated on my appearance, and
having to worry about whether I seemed masculine-looking enough, while
retaining my right to have a nurturing and feminine side.
I don't need to go through the rest of my life worrying
that complete strangers are going to treat me the same way as my child
molester.
My name is Joe. Some biological women are named Joe (or Jo)
too. The fact that my name is Joe, has absolutely nothing to do with my
external genital appearance, nor with whether I am more masculine or feminine.
Stop sexualizing me. And stop sexualizing your infants.
5. Reason #4: I Do Not Care About Being Misgendered
If you feel it necessary to use pronouns when referring to
me, then I would not be offended, hurt, insulted, nor shocked, if you guessed. Not even if you guessed incorrectly. I would be confused, but not offended.
I do not care about being misgendered (that is, identified
as a member of "the wrong gender"). I would rather be misgendered, than order people to use - or not to use - certain words, when referring to me.
6. Reason #5: I Do Not Want to Be Referred To
When I introduce
myself to a group, I assume that - if someone wishes to speak to me - they
will address me directly, calling me by my name.
I do not assume
that they will chiefly reference me by referring to me in the third person
while speaking to other people in the group.
If you need to
mention me to someone else in the group, then my first name "Joe"
will suffice perfectly, in place of whatever pronouns you may wish that I had
indicated that I prefer.
As I explained,
I do not wish to "force" nor "make" people call me by any
particular name(s) or gender pronoun(s), and I cannot force
anybody to say anything because I don't control their mouth.
But what I suggest,
is that, if someone wishes to refer to me, to another person in the group, then
there is no reason whatsoever why they need to
refer to me as "him" or "he".
Instead of
"him" or "her", say "Joe". Instead of
"he" or "she", say "Joe".
Now, it may feel
awkward to you to say "Joe" every five seconds instead of using
"he" as shorthand, but imagine how awkward I might
feel having my gender referred to every few seconds, or (even
worse) being prompted to focus on my gender as if it were an integral (or the
second-most important) part of my identity.
There is no
reason why you can't say to someone, "How do you think Joe feels about
that" instead of "How do you think he feels about
that". There is no reason why you can't say, "Let's invite Joe to the
event later this week" instead of "Let's invite him to
the event later this week."
If you think
that all of this is a bit too much for me to tell you about myself, then
imagine how I must feel when you ask me to talk about my sexual or gender
identity the very same moment that I meet you for the first time!
In fact, if your
question is "How do you think Joe feels about that", then why don't
you ask me how I feel about it, instead of asking someone
else!?
If we referred
to each other by their names when speaking to each other - and never gossiped
about each other behind one another's backs - then there would be almost zero
need for third-person pronouns (let alone gender pronouns).
The
American-Israeli philosopher Dr. Martin Buber explained, in his book I
and Thou, referring to someone as "it" or "he" has a
very different character from calling that person "you". Dr. Buber
(not "he", but Dr. Buber) explains that referring to someone in the
third person, separates that person from oneself (I). When you engage directly
with a person, and speak directly to them, you remove that separation, and
enter into a real, direct relationship with that person.
Buber even went
so far as to assert that this implies that there is no such thing as
"they" (a plural form of the third-person pronouns "it",
"he", and "she"). Referring to a group of people as
"they" not only separates them from yourself and the
person to whom you are speaking, it "others" them. Here, I use
"other" as a verb, meaning that calling people "they"
implies that they are so different from you and the person to whom you are
speaking, that it is almost as if they are not worthy of being spoken to
directly.
I would prefer that people not gossip about me behind my back. I would prefer that people refer to me as "Joe". But just because I might prefer that, that does not mean that it gives me any right to do anything about it.
Stop talking about me, and start talking to me.
7. Conclusion
I care more
about other people's freedom to use whichever words they please, than I am
worried about being misgendered. I care more about helping people not to feel
excluded or "othered" than I do about labeling them.
This is
why my preferred pronouns are "Shut the fuck up", "Joe-self" and
"Go-fuck-your-self".
Written on September 8th, 2021
Published on September 8th, 2021